Banned Index
← All lawsuits

2:24-cv-00055-DBB

PEN America v. Utah State Board of Education

U.S. District Court, District of Utah · Utah

OngoingThe case is active — no final ruling yet.

PEN America, authors (including the Vonnegut estate), and students challenged Utah's statewide book ban mechanism under HB 29 and HB 374. The lawsuit argues the 3-district threshold for statewide removal violates the First Amendment.

Filed

Jan 1, 2024

Plaintiff type

pen_america

Plaintiff

PEN America; authors; students; Vonnegut estate

Defendant

Utah State Board of Education

Laws challenged

Utah HB 0029

Sensitive Material Review Amendments

challenges

Challenges statewide removal threshold under HB 29

Utah HB 0374

Sensitive Materials in Schools

challenges

Also challenges sensitive materials definitions under HB 374

Notes

Challenges both HB 29 (statewide threshold) and HB 374 (sensitive materials definitions). Utah is the only state with a mandatory statewide removal cascade.